Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Post-event information influences memory

Excerpt from Dr. Elizabeth Loftus and Katherine Ketcham, The Myth of Repressed Memory (St. Martin's Press, 1994)

Dr. Loftus is professor of psychology at UC-Irvine and University of Washington and a prominent expert on memory.

http://faculty.washington.edu/eloftus/


She has written other books and articles that may be more pertinent, but I have a copy of this book, and the below passage summarizes some of her findings that I think are relevant to consideration of 9/11 eyewitness accounts.

This excerpt describes Dr. Loftus' testimony on behalf of a man prosecuted for murdering his daughter's friend twenty years earlier, based solely on his daughter's accusation that she now remembered her father killing her friend.

I took the stand . . . and for two hours discussed my experiments investigating memory acquisition. I explained to the court that memory fades with time, losing detail and accuracy; as time goes by, the weakened memories are increasingly vulnerable to "post-event information" -- facts, ideas, inferences, and opinions that become available to a witness after an event is completely over. I told the jury about a series of experiments I conducted featuring a shocking film simulation of a robbery. At the end of the short film, a child is shot in the face. Subjects who watched the film with the shocking ending were able to recall details with significantly less accuracy than subjects who watched a similar film without the violent ending.

This study, I explained, tells us about the distortions that can occur in the acquisition stage of memory, when an event occurs and information is laid down in the memory system. Other studies tell us about the retention and retrieval stages of memory, after a period of time goes by and we are asked to recall a particular event or experience. Hundreds of experiments involving tens of thousands of individuals have shown that post-event information can become incorporated into memory and contaminate, supplement, or distort the original memory.

I described a study I'd conducted in which subjects watched a film of a robbery involving a shooting and were then exposed to a television account of the event which contained erroneous details. When asked to recount what happened during the robbery, many subjects incorporated erroneous details from the television report into their account. Once these details were inserted into a person's mind through the technique of exposure to post-event information, they were adopted as the truth and protected as fiercely as the "real," original details. Subjects typically resisted any suggestion that their richly detailed memories might have been flawed or contaminated and asserted with great confidence what their revised and adapted memories told them they saw.


I now see that Dr. Loftus has a number of papers online here:

http://www.seweb.uci.edu/faculty/loftus/

I think the discussion of "misinformation effects" on page 5 of this paper is relevant to the 9/11 eyewitnesses:

http://webfiles.uci.edu/eloftus/WellsLoftus03.pdf

And in this paper as well:

http://webfiles.uci.edu/eloftus/MisinfoCurrentDirections92.pdf

4 comments:

pedro velasquez said...

A brief narrative description of the sportsbook journal article, document, or resource.This study examined the influence of misleading information on children's memory of a real-life event. After participating in a play session, 10 three-year-old children and 10 six-year-old children heard a narrative that included inaccurate information about the play session. The children were then presented with items from the play session (event items), bet nfl items from the narrative (suggested items), and novel items that were not present during the play session or narrative. Children were instructed to respond with a yes or no to indicate http://www.enterbet.com if they remembered seeing the item during the play session

kimberly sayer said...

I’ve been writing non-fiction books for 30 years. My first book, "Under the Influence" (co-authored by James Milam, Ph.D.) was published in 1981 and is considered a “classic” in the addiction field. I’ve written fourteen books; my latest is the just-published "Miss O'Dell" (www.missodell.com). My books have been published in sixteen foreign languages and have sold over 1.5 million copies.
costa rica fishing,
saltwater fishing,
offshore fishing,
manuel antonio,
salmon fishing,
sport fishing,
fishing guide.

http://www.fishingcostaricaexperts.com

viagra online said...

memory is far too much for the human being is something we all need!

viagra no prescription said...

Hi! Thanks so much for taking the time to share your post; this posting has evoked the most response.